After recently getting into the pistol red dot world I quickly realized one thing, duty style holsters are slim pickings. You basically have safariland and that’s it. Or so I thought. Enter the Blackhawk Omnivore! Yes Blackhawk, the same company that makes the (in my opinion) terribly designed serpa. But the omnivore is different, it doesn’t require trigger finger manipulation to deactivate the retention, and the retention mechanism seems to not be subject to locking up with foreign debris. Since my safariland was on 90 days back order and this Blackhawk was shipping immediately. I figured I’d give it a fair shake and put my Blackhawk bias aside.

The other very notable feature of this holster is it’s pretty much pistol agnostic. It retains and indexes on the light (or rail attachment if you get the non light bearing model) and Blackhawk claims it fits more than 200 different pistols. This would normally be a huge red flag for me as holsters, in general, should be designed to fit a specific gun. But with holsters like the Phlster floodlight and Armadillo lux being two exceptions, it’s not a deal breaker. I opted for the TLR-1/TLR-2 model.

What the TLR-1/TLR-2 version is, it’s better than a serpa, but it’s no safariland.

While I’d prefer to judge this holster on its own merits, it’s pretty much impossible to not compare it to it’s only competitor.

So my first impressions were not good, there were a bunch of plastic pieces and screws that you can/should add into different places and/or mounting platforms. I felt like I had ordered something from Alien gear. Turns out not only do none of these things work, but none are needed at least for my application. There were three different inserts for where the top of the slide meets the holster. I can only assume this is to reduce the play or wobble in the gun. None worked and only made reholstering more difficult. They were held in place by a tiny plastic peg, that I wouldn’t trust, anyhow they are labeled s,m,l. Then there was a piece of plastic labeled “for TLR-1”. Since the instructions/paperwork that came with the holster made no mention of what this was or why to use it, I can only assume you’re supposed to use it if you’re not using the TRL-2. To fill the space where the laser would be. More on that later. It also came with two different height attachments for the thumb drive release button. There are two different mounting platforms included, a paddle and a belt slide but with plastic things for adjusting ride height/belt size. The mounting platforms are the two that come with most “concealment” serpas that are plagued with problems, but the belt slide is the better of the two, so I attached it with the screws provided and attached the clips for my belt size.

Upon inserting the chosen gun, a g19 with trl-1 and Holosun 507c with irons mounted forward, it clicked into place with only a little play, good news! The thumb drive is way too low so I immediately installed the tallest option with the screws provided. I see no reason to not use the tallest option, as it’s the most intuitive, but not quite as intuitive as the safariland als.

I then installed the “tlr-1 adapter” since that was the light I was using. This was the best I could figure, since the instruction manual made no mention of this adapter or how to use it. It clicked into place and seemed semi solid, so I figured I was good to go. On draw strike number two the adapter went flying across the room, “must be operator error” I thought, so I spent a few minutes ensuring I installed it correctly, while looking for YouTube tutorials to help, there were none. As far as I could tell, that was the only way to install the adapter. So I reinstalled it, spending several minutes making sure there was no other way to put it in and it seemed good, then 6 more draw strokes later, it went flying across the room again. No worries though, the gun is retained just as well(as far as I can tell) without it. I later reinstalled it two more times and on installation number four it seemed to stay put. No idea what the problem was.

The draw is smooth enough, again it’s not a safariland, but it’s plenty fine. I certainly appreciated the natural thumb drive motion. Gun is retained well and the retention mechanism seems to be more than adequate for the “gun grab” situation.

The mounting platform isn’t very comfortable but it’s not extremely uncomfortable either. All that said, the mounting platforms are extremely flimsy and not something I would trust for serious use. But deep in the “box of bad ideas” I had some Blackhawk duty gear, that included some more robust mounting platforms. As it turns out, that doesn’t matter. Blackhawk uses a different thread pitch for their duty stuff than their concealment stuff, so none of it would work without going to the hardware store and figuring out what thread pitch, length and head size screws I would need, a task I had no interest in doing.

So I snooped around the interwebs and found a video on this holster from Chuck Presberg. He had run into the same issue and confirmed what I had found about screws and thread pitch. He had mentioned a safariland qls hack, so I looked for this. Turns out it’s fairly easy to modify a qls plate to work with the omnivore for mouthing to safariland attachments, which I prefer anyway. A little dremel and drill work and it was mounted and felt very secure. I should point out I wouldn’t recommend this for duty users since I’m sure the plate is somewhat structurally compromised, but it still feels much more solid than the mounting platforms it came with.

I carried the gun in this bastardized setup on both a ubl mid and a flex adapter, the draw and overall carry experience was pretty much on par with the same setups, as with a safariland holster. Again, the draw stroke is only slightly less efficient than safariland, but that could definitely be because of the thousands of repetitions I have from the competitor’s holster, so I can’t knock it. Maybe my initial impressions were wrong, maybe this is a quality holster.

This is when things took a turn. Several hundred draw strokes in, out came the gun but not the light. The light was still in the holster, held in place by the retention mechanism. Since the holster indexes on the light, not the gun itself, there was nothing holding the gun in the holster. Had I fallen or had someone grabbed the gun, it would have come out freely. Extremely concerned, I tightened the screw on the light as tight as I could without tools (streamlight says not to use tools to tighten the light) and added a whiteness mark, with a paint pen, to keep and eye on this. Hoping this was operator error, I continued the evaluation process, checking the whiteness mark every couple dozen draws. About a week and several hundred draw strokes later, my whiteness mark wasn’t lined up. Sure enough, the screw was loose yet again. The holster seems to be unscrewing the light from the gun. Now the instructions say to line up the slot in a specific orientation, I did that, same issue. I tightened it down as tight as I could get it and no issues drawing but it still would loosen up eventually. This is an issue for me. Now, checking the light screw is part of my daily PMCS. I’ve not had this issue with any other light bearing holster. Is it the end of the world? No, but something to be aware of? Yes

But wait there’s more! Not long after I started the review process, I got word from a friend that his agency (a large law enforcement agent in Florida) had circulated a memo disallowing the use of the omnivore for uniformed and non uniformed duty use, because of the opening at the trigger guard. According to them, it poses a risk for a negligent discharge because the opening for the light is large enough that it’s possible to depress the trigger of the gun while it’s holstered. A Blackhawk holster that can help facilitate a ND? You should see my shocked face. While this isn’t a new issue with light bearing holsters (there are cases of this happening with safariland) I had to explore this and see if the agency was being overly safe, or if this is a real concern, it’s a real concern. With my gun and my hand/finger size, it is absolutely possible for me to get my index finger inside the holster, inside the trigger guard, and press the trigger while establishing a grip on the holstered gun. Uh oh. It should be worth noting that I can indeed press the trigger while the gun is in some safariland light bearing holsters as well, but not while attempting to establish a grip. It has to be from a different angle and is much more difficult. This is a problem.

Overall, if you are an instructor that has a need to use a variety of guns depending on who you’re teaching, or need a range holster for reddot guns this might be an okay option to look at. If you carry a weird gun, that safariland doesn’t offer s rds holster for, this might be your only option. If you have to use a Blackhawk, it’s better than a serpa, but all that said, I’d pass on this holster. And I really wanted to like it.

Firearms Insider Reviews - 8 Key Points

CLAIM TO FAME:

Near universal retention holster that is red dot compatible

TARGET MARKET:

People needing a retention holster for use with a red dot and light or for a variety of guns.

FNBS (FEATURES & BENEFITS OF THIS PRODUCT):

Thumb drive retention
Red dot compatible
Indexes on the light
Fits numerous handguns
Thumb activated retention

WHAT OTHER AESTHETIC OPTIONS OR FINISHES ARE AVAILABLE?

TLR-1/ TLR-2, x300u, no light(rail still required)

What others are saying:

Denis B

5.0 out of 5 stars

Works perfectly with my Glock G22 and S/W M and P 40.

As a range/competition holster this product works great. It's not suitable for duty carry and it says so right in the instructions. I carried a Blackhawk Serpa Level III for years but none of the ranges I shoot at or companies offering instruction will allow it. This has saved me the trouble and cost of 2 rigs. One holster does it all. Very happy with this product.

Anthony M.

NOT SAFE!!! DO NOT BUY IF LAW ENFORCEMENT

I've had this holster for about 18 months now and it seemed okay, a little wobbly but overall a good fit, as the time passed it became more and more loose and I had to tighten the screws every other day. Well today, I got in a foot pursuit with a dangerous felon and the piece that secures the gun to the holster snapped off causing my gun to fall out. The part that attaches to the picatinny rail detached from the rail and remained locked into the holster. My gun fell out WHILE IN A FOOT PURSUIT!!!!! This could've very well cost me my life. Because of this, I no longer trust this holster or any holster that attaches using the picatinny rail. I will immediately get rid of this holster and purchase a safariland holster.